Skip to Main Content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.

Comprehensive & Systematic Reviews

A guide to resources to help with conducting comprehensive reviews & services available from eTreadwell librarians

Documenting Workflow

Documenting each step of your systematic review is of the utmost importance. Be sure to document all the data you need to report your review according to the standards in the PRISMA Checklist

For the search process itself, the following things should be recorded to ensure that your searches are truly replicable:

  • The databases the searches were run in. This should include the database (ex: MEDLINE) and the database provider (ex: Ovid). 
  • The dates the searches were conducted.
  • Who conducted the database searches.
  • The full search strategies for each database.
  • Information about any limits that were utilized, such as date or language limits.
  • Information about whether the search was saved to a team members' account, and what name the search was saved as.
  • The number of citations retrieved from each database before deduplicating.
  • The total number of citations left after deduplicating.  

Keeping Track of Citations

Conducting a systematic review involves keeping track of thousands of citations. We highly recommend using bibliographic software for this task. Bibliographic software helps organize citations, remove duplicate citations from your database searches, and can help you once you begin writing your final report by formatting your in text citations and bibliography. 

Examples of bibliographic software programs include EndNote, Zotero, and Mendeley. 

Learn more about..

Data Extraction and Aggregation

There are software programs (both free and proprietary) available that can assist your team in screening citations, extracting data, and aggregating data. A searchable database of these programs is available from "The Systematic Review Toolbox," linked below. 

You should utilize a standardized form or spreadsheet for data extraction. Some example templates are below.